Thriller · Free kit
The Witch
After losing her job and apartment, Julia Barlow retreats to Pemberton — her family’s sprawling estate in rural northern Massachusetts — to check on her aging grandmother Letitia and the aunt who shares the house. The grandfather clock stops at 3:41 a.m., lights flicker, and a voice cries for help from rooms that should be empty. Museum curator Henry Ziegler wants the property; Julia’s father pushes a sale and assisted living; great-aunt Ethel fights to keep the past buried. In 1692, Caroline Eldridge is accused of witchcraft on the land Archibald Eldridge calls his, while Jonas Reeve is scapegoated as the Night Reaper. Two centuries braid into one inheritance, and every ghost story may be a cover for something human, recent, and far worse.
“Some hauntings are history. Some are alibis.”
Complete free book club kit
BookClubee may earn a commission from Bookshop.org purchases, which supports independent bookshops.
Plan your meeting
Spoiler warning — best after finishing the book
The Witch Discussion Questions
20 free questions written for The Witch. No obvious right answers — built to spark real disagreement.
1. Julia arrives at Pemberton because she has nowhere else to go — not because she wants a family reunion. How does that desperation change the way you read her first nights in the house?
Warm Up
2. The grandfather clock stopping at 3:41 a.m. is one of the first “wrong” details. At what point did you decide the estate was genuinely haunted versus expertly staged?
Warm Up
3. Henry Ziegler frames the Woodhaven Museum’s interest as preservation. When did you start trusting — or distrusting — his politeness?
Warm Up
4. Gram (Letitia) and “Ethel” share a house but not the same goals. Which small domestic detail first made you suspect their partnership was more fragile than it looked?
Warm Up
5. In 1692, Caroline Eldridge is accused while Archibald Eldridge controls the narrative. Does McFadden make you feel the trial as history — or as a template the present-day plot repeats?
Warm Up
6. Julia’s father supports selling Pemberton and moving Gram into assisted living. Is that pragmatic care for an aging parent — or abandonment dressed up as practicality?
Debate Starter
7. “Ethel” opposes the sale with fierce certainty. Before the reveal, did you read her as a protector of family legacy — or someone guarding a secret at any cost?
Debate Starter
8. Jonas Reeve is wrongly accused as the Night Reaper while the real killer hides in respectability. Does the novel argue that communities prefer a convenient monster to an inconvenient neighbor?
Debate Starter
9. Caroline and Jonas escape under borrowed names; Molly Howe becomes part of the Barlow line. Is survival through identity theft forgivable when the alternative is death?
Debate Starter
10. Archibald Eldridge is revealed as the Night Reaper murderer. Does making the “founding” patriarch the villain undercut New England nostalgia — or simply tell the truth gothic fiction often whispers?
Debate Starter
11. Celia Caine murdered the real Ethel decades ago and wore her life like a costume. Is long-con identity fraud worse than a single violent act — or just violence stretched across time?
Debate Starter
12. The “haunting” — voices, flickers, clock stops — is fabricated to control Julia and the estate. When fiction uses fake ghosts, does it diminish real grief in the house — or expose how easily fear replaces inquiry?
Debate Starter
13. Henry wants Pemberton for the museum’s story. Julia needs a home. Gram needs safety. Whose need should win if only one can?
Debate Starter
14. Hitty Atkins’s friendship with Caroline in 1692 is a lifeline in a lethal season. How much does the historical thread depend on women trusting women when institutions fail them?
Debate Starter
15. Discovering bones in the yard reframes every creak in Pemberton. Did the physical evidence feel like the novel’s moral center — or one twist among many?
Deep Dive
16. Julia is both heir and investigator in a house that trained her to look away. What does the book suggest about how families teach younger members not to ask certain questions?
Deep Dive
17. Gram’s age and dependence make her both vulnerable and potentially complicit in old silences. How did your sympathy for Letitia shift once the scope of Pemberton’s secrets became clear?
Deep Dive
18. Dual timelines often mirror each other. Which parallel between Caroline’s century and Julia’s felt most deliberate — accusation, erasure, stolen name, or something else?
Deep Dive
19. Finding original Archie and Molly remains closes a historical loop. Does unearthing the past heal the Barlow line — or simply prove that some inheritances are built on violence?
Deep Dive
20. By the final chapters, what is Pemberton: sanctuary, crime scene, museum piece, or something Julia must redefine for herself?
Deep Dive