BookClubee
← Books
Cover of The Witch by Freida McFadden

Thriller · Free kit

The Witch

Freida McFadden

After losing her job and apartment, Julia Barlow retreats to Pemberton — her family’s sprawling estate in rural northern Massachusetts — to check on her aging grandmother Letitia and the aunt who shares the house. The grandfather clock stops at 3:41 a.m., lights flicker, and a voice cries for help from rooms that should be empty. Museum curator Henry Ziegler wants the property; Julia’s father pushes a sale and assisted living; great-aunt Ethel fights to keep the past buried. In 1692, Caroline Eldridge is accused of witchcraft on the land Archibald Eldridge calls his, while Jonas Reeve is scapegoated as the Night Reaper. Two centuries braid into one inheritance, and every ghost story may be a cover for something human, recent, and far worse.

“Some hauntings are history. Some are alibis.”

Complete free book club kit

Buy the book Get Premium Kit

BookClubee may earn a commission from Bookshop.org purchases, which supports independent bookshops.

Plan your meeting

Reading schedule · Book vote

The Witch Characters

Spoiler-aware but intrigue-first.

Julia Barlow

The granddaughter who returns to Pemberton with no job, no apartment, and no patience left for family mythology.

The Vibe
Julia is practical, bruised, and tired of being the person who adapts. Pemberton should be refuge; instead it becomes a puzzle where every kindness might be strategy and every ghost might be theater.
Their Contradiction
On the surface: A reluctant caretaker trying to stabilize Gram’s world. Underneath: She needs the estate to mean safety — which makes her vulnerable to stories designed to control her.
Why Readers Love / Hate Them
Readers root for her quickly because she asks the questions the house trained others not to ask — even when the answers terrify her.
Most Revealing Moment
Watch when Julia stops reacting to the haunting and starts asking who benefits from her fear.
Book Club Hot Take
Is Julia a final-generation truth-teller — or just the first one desperate enough to risk the family’s peace?

Caroline Eldridge

Archibald Eldridge’s first wife, accused of witchcraft in 1692 on land that will become Pemberton.

The Vibe
Caroline is sharp, loyal, and trapped inside a community that converts fear into spectacle. Her story is not fantasy witchcraft — it is accusation as property law with a bonfire.
Their Contradiction
On the surface: The “witch” the town needs. Underneath: A woman who understands survival may require becoming someone else entirely.
Why Readers Love / Hate Them
Historical chapters often split the room between rage at the injustice and dread at what survival costs.
Most Revealing Moment
Watch what Caroline chooses when the town decides her guilt before her trial begins.
Book Club Hot Take
Is Caroline the novel’s moral compass — or proof that even victims can inherit violent systems when escape is the only option?

Letitia "Gram" Barlow

The aging matriarch of Pemberton, sharp-eyed and entrenched in the family’s long silence.

The Vibe
Gram is not a frail plot device — she is memory in human form. She knows which doors stay closed, which names are never spoken, and which relatives are performing love instead of offering it.
Their Contradiction
On the surface: A grandmother who needs care and deserves protection. Underneath: Decades of complicity or selective blindness that Julia’s arrival threatens to disturb.
Why Readers Love / Hate Them
Readers often waver between fierce protectiveness and frustration — exactly where the book wants you.
Most Revealing Moment
Watch how Gram responds when selling Pemberton becomes real — not as abstract legacy, but as exposure.
Book Club Hot Take
Is Gram a victim of Celia’s long con — or an elder who traded truth for the comfort of a curated past?

Ethel (Celia Caine)

The great-aunt who is not Ethel — a woman who murdered the real Ethel ~50 years ago and stole her identity.

The Vibe
Celia performs “Ethel” with the confidence of someone who has rehearsed every family ritual. She opposes the sale, engineers the haunting, and treats Pemberton as a stage where fear keeps witnesses quiet.
Their Contradiction
On the surface: The eccentric aunt guarding tradition. Underneath: A predator who discovered that ghost stories are excellent crowd control.
Why Readers Love / Hate Them
The reveal typically produces audible gasps — and immediate re-reads of every polite conversation she ever had.
Most Revealing Moment
Watch the first time Julia’s questions threaten Celia’s script — and how quickly “supernatural” events escalate.
Book Club Hot Take
Is Celia McFadden’s scariest creation because she’s supernatural — or because she’s ordinary malice with decades of practice?

Henry Ziegler

Woodhaven Museum curator who wants Pemberton — politely, persistently, and with a historian’s eye for what stories sell.

The Vibe
Henry speaks in preservation and public good. He knows names, dates, and how to make Julia feel that selling is civic duty rather than family fracture.
Their Contradiction
On the surface: A professional saving local history. Underneath: A man whose interest in the estate may outrun his concern for the people still living in it.
Why Readers Love / Hate Them
Groups usually split on Henry: helpful outsider or elegant vulture. Both readings have evidence.
Most Revealing Moment
Watch how Henry frames Caroline’s tragedy — as human suffering or as exhibit copy.
Book Club Hot Take
Would Pemberton be safer in a museum — or does institutional ownership just freeze the same lies in glass?

Archibald "Archie" Eldridge

The 17th-century patriarch who accuses Caroline, hides behind respectability, and is revealed as the Night Reaper murderer.

The Vibe
Archie embodies the founding myth: land, authority, and the power to name who counts as human. The Night Reaper legend is his diversion — a monster story that points away from his own hands.
Their Contradiction
On the surface: Wronged husband and community leader. Underneath: A serial violence hidden inside piety and property rights.
Why Readers Love / Hate Them
Readers rarely sympathize — the book treats him as the ancestor of Pemberton’s rot, not its ghost.
Most Revealing Moment
Watch who the town chooses to burn when Archie needs a scapegoat besides himself.
Book Club Hot Take
Is Archie history’s villain — or the template Celia learned when she built a haunting instead of a bonfire?

Molly Howe & Jonas Reeve

Servant Molly (Barlow ancestor) and Jonas Reeve — wrongly accused as the Night Reaper, both surviving by living under borrowed names.

The Vibe
Molly and Jonas are the book’s survival pair: intimacy forged under accusation, escape purchased with erasure. Their legacy is literally Julia’s bloodline — built on names that were never theirs to begin with.
Their Contradiction
On the surface: Supporting figures in a witch-trial past. Underneath: Proof that Pemberton’s “honored” ancestry may begin with theft of identity as surely as theft of land.
Why Readers Love / Hate Them
The Jonas misdirection often frustrates readers on first read — then impresses them on reflection.
Most Revealing Moment
Watch when Caroline and Jonas choose borrowed lives — and what that choice costs the generations that follow.
Book Club Hot Take
Are Molly and Jonas heroes of survival — or evidence that every beautiful family tree hides a forged branch?

Character Dynamics Map

Present day: Julia enters a triangle of control — Gram’s fragile authority, Celia-as-Ethel’s manufactured terror, and Henry’s institutional appetite for Pemberton — while her father’s push to sell treats the estate as a problem to liquidate. Past: Caroline and Jonas are sacrificed to narratives Archie writes; Molly’s place in the lineage rewrites who the Barlows think they are. The dual timeline rhymes accusation with performance, fire with flickering lights, and stolen names with stolen identity. By the end, Julia must decide whether Pemberton can be home once both the ghosts and the liars are stripped away.

Superlatives

Award categories built to spark arguments (in a good way).

  • Most Likely to Stage a Haunting to Avoid a Conversation

    Winner: Celia Caine (as Ethel)

    Voices, flickers, and clock stops — all calibrated to keep Julia afraid instead of curious.

    Close second: Archibald Eldridge

    Do you agree, or would you have picked Archie’s Night Reaper legend instead?

  • Most Likely to Quote Property Law During a Family Crisis

    Winner: Julia’s father

    Assisted living and sale paperwork arrive faster than empathy.

    Close second: Henry Ziegler

    Who makes a worse dinner guest: the dad or the curator?

  • Most Likely to Survive by Becoming Someone Else

    Winner: Caroline Eldridge

    When the town chooses guilt, she chooses a borrowed name and a borrowed life.

    Close second: Jonas Reeve

    Is Caroline’s survival more impressive or more heartbreaking than Jonas’s?

  • Most Likely to Be Blamed for What a Respectable Man Did

    Winner: Jonas Reeve

    The Night Reaper label sticks because the community prefers a outsider monster.

    Close second: Caroline Eldridge

    Which wrongful accusation felt more infuriating to your group?

  • Most Likely to Opposes Selling Until the Bones Speak

    Winner: Celia Caine (as Ethel)

    Exposure threatens her costume — not just the family’s feelings.

    Close second: Gram

    Was Ethel’s opposition ever partly genuine care for Gram?

  • Most Likely to Treat Your Trauma Like Exhibit Copy

    Winner: Henry Ziegler

    Preservation can sound like compassion while eyeing the deed.

    Close second: Archibald Eldridge

    Is Henry exploitative — or just professionally blind?

  • Most Likely to Stop a Clock at 3:41 a.m. for Drama

    Winner: Celia Caine (as Ethel)

    The grandfather clock is theater with brass gears.

    Close second: Whoever Julia blamed before she caught on

    What everyday object in your house would you use as a prop?

  • Most Likely to Dig Until the Yard Gives an Answer

    Winner: Julia Barlow

    She has nothing left to lose except the lies.

    Close second: Henry Ziegler

    Would Julia have found the truth without pressure from outsiders?

  • Most Likely to Deserve a Museum Wing and a Restraining Order

    Winner: Archibald Eldridge

    Founding father energy, Night Reaper receipts.

    Close second: Celia Caine

    Who damaged more generations: Archie or Celia?

  • Most Likely to Be the Real Monster Under the Gothic Roof

    Winner: Celia Caine

    No supernatural excuse — just decades of control.

    Close second: Archibald Eldridge

    Does history’s monster or present-day monster hit harder?

  • Most Likely to Friend You Through a Witch Trial

    Winner: Hitty Atkins

    Caroline’s lifeline when institutions fail.

    Close second: Molly Howe

    Did Hitty get enough page time for the role she plays?

  • Most Likely to Keep Secrets for the Sake of Peace

    Winner: Letitia "Gram" Barlow

    Silence as a love language — until it isn’t.

    Close second: Julia’s father

    When does protecting Gram become enabling Celia?

  • Most Likely to Inherit a Name Built on a Lie

    Winner: Julia Barlow

    Molly’s lineage means Julia’s identity is legally true and morally complicated.

    Close second: Caroline Eldridge

    Does knowing the ancestry change how you read Julia’s fight for Pemberton?

  • Most Likely to Cry for Help from a Room That Is Empty — On Purpose

    Winner: Celia Caine (as Ethel)

    The voice is a leash.

    Close second: Any guest at Pemberton before Julia

    What moment made you angriest at the manipulation?

  • Most Likely to Close the Historical Loop with Bones and Brutal Honesty

    Winner: The Pemberton yard

    Original Archie and Molly remains don’t care about family mythology.

    Close second: Julia Barlow

    Was the yard reveal satisfying — or one twist too many?