
Satire · Free kit
Yesteryear
Tradwife influencer Natalie Heller Mills sells raw milk, sourdough, and a pioneer life on Idaho's Yesteryear Ranch — nannies, producers, and industrial ovens safely off-camera. Then she wakes in what seems to be 1855: no electricity, children she does not recognize, and a husband who is suddenly competent and cruel. Caro Claire Burke's debut is a satirical thriller about fame, faith, and the performance of womanhood, told in two timelines that refuse to let the feed stay pretty.
“My name is Natalie Heller Mills, and I was perfect at being alive.”
Complete free book club kit
BookClubee may earn a commission from Bookshop.org purchases, which supports independent bookshops.
Plan your meeting
Yesteryear Hosting Guide
A free, printable-minded plan for hosting Yesteryear.
Invite hook
“A tradwife with millions of followers wakes up in 1855. Come talk Yesteryear — the ranch, the feed, and whether the past was ever the point.”
The question you’re arguing about: If the life you posted was a set, and you woke up inside the century you were selling, would you run — or try to ace the test?
Shopping list
- □A sourdough loaf (bakery stand-in is fine) — Natalie's grid signature
- □Jam and butter in mason jars, labeled a little too prettily
- □Farm-style eggs: a frittata or egg salad, nothing fussy
- □Biscuits or cornbread and a bowl of fruit
- □Tea, coffee, lemonade, juice, and sparkling water
- □A gingham runner or checked napkins; extra mason jars as glasses
- □Printed two-sided caption cards for the surprise touch
- □Bingo cards and extra pens
Day-of timeline
- 0–10 minWelcome & icebreakers (readers, not spoilers — keep Shannon's interview, the tonic, and Clementine's car off the welcome mat)
- 10–20 minTrivia warm-up — ranch name, Harvard, 1855, Sassafras, the microphone
- 20–50 minMain discussion (start with the feed vs the nannies and the Angry Women; save Mary, the Manosphere trailer, and the prison interview for last)
- 50–65 minSpeed debate: victim vs author, or whether the ending is a satisfying moral
- 65–75 minBingo, one-word rating, pick next month
Surprise touch
Leave a two-sided card at each seat. Front: an Instagram-perfect caption — homemade jam, farm eggs, golden-hour sourdough. Back, flipped only after discussion starts: a pioneer chore list in plain type — firewood, laundry, chickens, no caption. It is the novel's joke as an object, not a lecture.
Wrap-up
- □Group photo with the sourdough and the flipped caption cards in the frame
- □Quick rating round: 1–5 stars and one word each (expect "acidic," "twist," and "I would have run")
- □Vote on next month's book together
